Big Show is #AllElite

[Stone Cold Tea]

I agree they would probably be tiered the same if I decided to ever do one of those Tier memes. They're both people you'd want for your company as Edge was a work horse and Big Show was the ultimate company guy. I've been watching all of the AE on WWE Network and Big Show had so many ups and downs even in his first year. I'll be honest as well, I really enjoyed the Big Show breaking into Hollywood gimmick.

Reason I'd say Big Show was a bigger draw is simply due to his size. His matches against Akebono ad Mayweather were perfect proof of this. He has a unique presence to him.

Edge for 5 star matches and Big Show for the spectacle.

[Fallout]

Edge is absolutely a bigger star than Show. He had a time period where he could call himself one of the greats of his era alongside Cena, Orton, Batista and Undertaker.

Big Show is in that tier below, a solid force in his own right, but from what I remember, he's had three world title reigns (not counting the ECW title, and being generous and counting that 45 second one he lost to Bryan cashing in MITB). Edge is in the double digits in that regard IIRC. And Show wasn't even remotely close to Andre in terms of spectacle and drawing power.

[BestSportsEntertainer]

Edge is one of the best heels of all time. He has many all-time great rivalries and matches and 11 world championship reigns.

Big Show was an upper mid-carder after 2003. He had celebrity matches, a couple of tag team championship reigns, and a brief world championship run (though the title was upper mid card by then). He turned heel and face so many times he became a meme. He's simply not close to Edge's level. He was a spectacle, and it didn't take long for the spectacle to wear off.

[Stone Cold Tea]

Edge vs Big Show in the SCF Tournament.

Make it happen!

[#AbsoluteUnit]

Good for him.