I've voted for Edge. I don't think either of these are true top tier talents. Michaels was a great ring worker but at the point he was winning everything was a pretty terrible real life person, which made him undependable. Edge was undependable because of his injury issues, but a very solid character guy. The fact is Michaels is probably held in higher esteem than he should be, and Edge is probably held in lower esteem than he should be. They are both great, but I've based this on the fact that Edge actually beat Michaels in the only match I can remember them having at the 2005 Royal Rumble.