Originally Posted by
klunderbunker
No real need to put them together as they were doing just fine on their own.
I wouldn't, because you're confusing the difference between over and popular (which is a very, very common mistake).
Popular is fleeting. Otis is popular. Orange Cassidy is popular. They do something that gets a reaction from the fans and it could work for weeks or even months. That's just popularity though.
Over is permanent (or close to it). The fans have accepted you no matter what you are doing. Chris Jericho is over. Fans aren't going to be tired or bored of him no matter what he does. Rey Mysterio is over. Yeah he's old and banged up and he's in a horrible story, but the fans know that he's great (note that you can absolutely be talented and popular without being over, which is where a lot of wrestlers are).
Think of it like this. Mysterio is in a horrible story that won't go away, but you don't hear people saying Mysterio is worthless. They understand that it's not Rey, but the material that he's doing. People are tired of what he's doing, but not him. You don't quite get that with Otis, who while very charismatic, has yet to show he's more than a one trick pony.
So no, Tajiri and Spike weren't over. They were popular and could have been on their way to being over, but they weren't there yet.
Does that make sense (which I say as non-condescendingly as possible even though it sounds like it is)?